A Korean defined benefit (DB) retirement pension is a plan in which the employer builds up, with a financial company, the retirement benefits it will pay later. How much must be built up is set by law. Art. 16(1) of the Employee Retirement Benefit Security Act requires the employer, at the end of each business year, to hold a reserve of at least the minimum reserve — the standard liability reserve times a rate set by Presidential Decree — and Decree Art. 5(1) with Enforcement Rule Art. 4-2 set that rate at 100% from 1 January 2022. If the reserve is below 95% of the minimum, the employer must close at least a third of the shortfall within 1 year (Decree Art. 7), and above 150% of the standard liability reserve a refund may be requested (Act Art. 16(4)). Enter the standard liability reserve and the reserve, and the checker shows the funding ratio, the result and the amount to close within a year.
1. Standard liability reserve — the larger of the Act Art. 16(1) item 1 amount (present value of benefit costs to expected retirement minus present value of future contributions) and the item 2 amount (benefit costs for service to the end of the business year).
2. Minimum funding ratio — 100% from 1 January 2022 (Enforcement Rule Art. 4-2 item 3). It was 90% for 2019 to 2021.
3. The 95% line — if the reserve is below 95% of the minimum, at least a third of the shortfall ratio is closed within 1 year after the end of the previous business year (Decree Art. 7(1) and (2)).
4. Our example — a ₩1,200,000,000 standard liability reserve with a ₩1,080,000,000 reserve is a 90.0% funding ratio, and ₩40,000,000 must be closed within a year (our arithmetic).
Checker
Results update as you type. The item 1 and item 2 amounts are worked out by the pension provider at the actuarial check using the Ministry of Employment and Labor's method (Enforcement Rule Art. 5), so enter the figures the provider gave you. The reserve follows Enforcement Rule Art. 6: the 12-month average market value, held at 90% or 110% of the year-end value if it is at or below 90% or at or above 110%; deposits and other products that rise steadily over time, or a realised loss, use the year-end value. Leave the average at 0 to use the year-end value. The 90% and 110% amounts drop fractions of a won. “A third of the shortfall ratio” is counted as (minimum reserve − reserve) ÷ 3, rounding fractions of a won up (our arithmetic). The notified rates for plans that count service before the plan began (the table in the “three layers” section) are not included.
The rules as written
| Provision | What the text says | Point to note (our reading) |
|---|---|---|
| Act Art. 16(1) | An employer that has set up a DB plan shall, to secure the ability to pay benefits, hold as a reserve at the end of each business year at least the amount (“minimum reserve”) found by multiplying the larger of the following amounts (“standard liability reserve”) by a rate of at least 60% set by Presidential Decree. | The Act sets only a 60% floor and delegates the actual rate |
| Act Art. 16(1) items 1 and 2 | 1. the present value of expected benefit costs for the service period up to members' expected retirement, as at the last day of the business year, minus the present value of expected contributions for future service … 2. the expected benefit costs for the service of members and former members up to the last day of the business year … | Item 1 assumes continued service, item 2 that everyone leaves today |
| Decree Art. 5(1) | “A rate set by Presidential Decree” means a rate of at least 80% set by Ordinance of the Ministry of Employment and Labor. | Delegated once more |
| Enforcement Rule Art. 4-2 | 2. From 1 January 2019 to 31 December 2021: 90% 3. From 1 January 2022: 100% | Today the minimum reserve equals the standard liability reserve |
| Act Art. 16(2) | The provider shall, within 6 months after the end of each business year, check whether the reserve exceeds the minimum reserve and tell the employer; where it is below the minimum reserve, the result shall also be given to the workers' representative. | The actuarial check |
| Decree Art. 6(1) | Where the reserve is below the minimum reserve, a union joined by a majority of workers shall also be told in writing, or, with no such union, all workers in writing or by electronic means. | Below 100%, the workers find out too |
| Act Art. 16(3) · Decree Art. 7(1) | Where the reserve falls short of a level set by Presidential Decree, the employer shall close the shortfall. / That level means 95% of the minimum reserve. | The duty to close applies only below 95% |
| Decree Art. 7(2) | Where the reserve falls short of the level in para. 1, the employer shall close at least a third of the shortfall ratio against the minimum reserve, by paying contributions or otherwise, within 1 year after the end of the previous business year. | It need not all be closed at once |
| Act Art. 16(4) | Where the reserve at year end exceeds the standard liability reserve, the employer may offset the excess against future contributions, and where it exceeds 150% of the standard liability reserve and the employer asks for a refund, the provider may return that excess to the employer. | The scope of “that excess” for a refund is discussed below |
| Enforcement Rule Art. 6 | 1. Value the reserve at the average market value over the 12 months before the end of the business year; where that is 90% or less, or 110% or more, of the year-end market value, use 90% or 110% respectively. 2. Notwithstanding item 1, where a loss has been realised or for deposits, instalment savings and other methods whose value rises steadily over time, use the year-end market value. | An average, held within 10% either side |
| Act Art. 17(2) · Decree Art. 8 item 4 | The employer shall have the provider pay, within the reserve, the full benefit owed (in cases such as business failure set by Presidential Decree, the amount at the ratio of the reserve to the Art. 16(1) item 2 amount). / 4. Where the check under Act Art. 16(2) shows the ratio of the reserve to the standard liability reserve below the rate in Art. 5(1) … | Below 100%, the part the provider pays a leaver first can shrink |
| Act Art. 17(3) | Where the benefit paid by the provider falls short of the level under Art. 15, the employer shall pay the shortfall to the worker within 14 days from the day the payment became due. | The employer pays the gap directly |
Five worked cases — our examples
| Case (our example, standard liability reserve ₩1,200,000,000) | Result | How (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|
| Reserve ₩1,080,000,000 | Funding ratio 90.0% — ₩40,000,000 within a year | Below the 95% line of ₩1,140,000,000. Shortfall ₩120,000,000 ÷ 3 = ₩40,000,000 |
| Reserve ₩1,160,000,000 | Funding ratio 96.6% — no duty to close, workers notified | Below the ₩1,200,000,000 minimum but above the 95% line of ₩1,140,000,000 |
| Reserve ₩1,860,000,000 | Funding ratio 155.0% — offset ₩660,000,000 · above the 150% line ₩60,000,000 | ₩1,860,000,000 − ₩1,200,000,000 = ₩660,000,000; ₩1,860,000,000 − ₩1,800,000,000 = ₩60,000,000 |
| Year-end value ₩1,000,000,000 · 12-month average ₩850,000,000 · market product | Funding ratio 75.0% — ₩100,000,000 within a year | The average is below 90% of year-end value (₩900,000,000), so ₩900,000,000 counts. Shortfall ₩300,000,000 ÷ 3 |
| Same ₩1,000,000,000 · deposit type | Funding ratio 83.3% — ₩66,666,667 within a year | Year-end ₩1,000,000,000 as is. Shortfall ₩200,000,000 ÷ 3, rounded up |
The fourth and fifth rows have the same ₩1,000,000,000 at year end, yet the reserve counts as ₩900,000,000 or ₩1,000,000,000 depending on how it is invested. Products whose value moves use the 12-month average, so a company whose assets were low through the year gets less credit even if they recover by year end, while in a year that ends with a sharp fall the average holds the figure up (our reading). In the first row, if the item 2 amount is ₩1,100,000,000, then when someone leaves that year in a case such as business failure, the provider pays first at ₩1,080,000,000 ÷ ₩1,100,000,000 = 98.1% and the employer pays the rest directly within 14 days (Act Art. 17(2) and (3), our arithmetic).
Three layers of delegation — from 60% to 100%
The minimum funding ratio only becomes a number after going down through the Act, the Decree and the Enforcement Rule. Act Art. 16(1) says “a rate of at least 60% set by Presidential Decree”, Decree Art. 5(1) “a rate of at least 80% set by Ministry ordinance”, and Enforcement Rule Art. 4-2 “from 1 January 2022: 100%”. So today the minimum reserve is the same amount as the standard liability reserve. It was 90% from 2019 to 2021, and item 1, which covered the period before that, was deleted on 18 May 2022.
The proviso to Act Art. 16(1) uses a different rate where service before the plan was set up is counted as membership, and Decree Art. 5(2) says the Minister of Employment and Labor notifies that rate by years of past service and years since joining.
That notice is the “Minimum funding ratio of defined benefit retirement pension plans for past service” (Ministry of Employment and Labor Notice No. 2022-37, in force 13 April 2022). Its table for “periods from 1 January 2022” sets the rate for past service by years of past service (under 1, 1 to under 3, 3 to under 6, 6 to under 10, and 10 or more) and by year since joining (from year 1). Below, that table is set out one row per band of past service (rows and columns swapped by us).
| Years of past service | Rate from year 1 after joining | Year it reaches 100/100 |
|---|---|---|
| Under 1 year | 60, 70, 80, 90 (out of 100) | Year 5 |
| 1 to under 3 years | 30, 60, 70, 80, 90 (out of 100) | Year 6 |
| 3 to under 6 years | 20, 40, 60, 70, 80, 90 (out of 100) | Year 7 |
| 6 to under 10 years | 15, 30, 45, 60, 70, 80, 90 (out of 100) | Year 8 |
| 10 years or more | 12, 24, 36, 48, 60, 70, 80, 90 (out of 100) | Year 9 |
The notice works out the minimum funding ratio for the whole membership period as “[(all members' average past service × the minimum funding ratio for that period) + (all members' average membership since the plan was set up × 100%)] / all members' average total membership including past service” (our translation), and says that from the year after the past-service rate reaches 100/100, 100/100 must be kept for the whole period. For example, average past service of 5 years (the 3 to under 6 band) in year 2 after joining (40/100) with 2 years of average membership since set-up gives (5 × 40% + 2 × 100%) ÷ 7 = about 57.1% (our example and arithmetic — picking the band by average past service is our reading). The checker does not include this rate and uses 100% only.
Between 95% and 100% — a notice goes out but no duty to close
There are two lines. If the reserve is below the minimum reserve (100%), the provider must tell not only the employer but also a majority union or all workers (Act Art. 16(2) proviso, Decree Art. 6(1)). The duty to close the shortfall, however, arises only below 95% of the minimum reserve (Act Art. 16(3), Decree Art. 7(1)). The second row, at 96.6%, sits between the two.
Below 95%, Decree Art. 7(2) requires closing “at least a third of the shortfall ratio against the minimum reserve” within 1 year after the end of the previous business year. In the first row the shortfall ratio is 10 percentage points; a third of it, just over 3.3 points, comes to ₩40,000,000 (our arithmetic). The checker counts this as (minimum reserve − reserve) ÷ 3. After closing a third, the plan is checked again the next year, so we read it as a structure that narrows the gap year by year rather than all at once (our reading).
Above 150% — offset and refund
Act Art. 16(4) allows two things. If the reserve exceeds the standard liability reserve, the excess may be offset against future contributions; if it exceeds 150% of the standard liability reserve and the employer asks, the provider may refund “that excess”. Whether “that excess” means everything above the standard liability reserve or only the part above the 150% line can be read two ways from the sentence alone. The checker shows both, and the refund row uses the part above the 150% line as our reading. In the third row that is ₩660,000,000 available to offset and ₩60,000,000 above the 150% line.
Checklist
- ☐ Does the provider's actuarial check show both the item 1 and item 2 amounts?
- ☐ Was the reserve valued at the 12-month average or at year-end value (investment type)?
- ☐ If the ratio is below 100%, were workers notified too?
- ☐ If below 95%, is there a plan to close a third of the shortfall within 1 year after the previous business year ended?
- ☐ Was past service counted as membership (then work out the rate with the notice table and formula)?
- ☐ If above 150%, will you offset or ask for a refund?
Questions that remain
As a worker, do I get less if the funding ratio is low?
The DB benefit level itself is set by Act Art. 15, so the funding ratio does not reduce what you are owed. But if the part the provider pays first shrinks under Act Art. 17(2) and (3), the employer must pay the rest directly within 14 days (our reading). Getting that part when the employer is in trouble belongs to wage claim protection, which this page does not cover.
Is there a minimum reserve for DC plans?
In a DC plan the employer pays a set contribution into each member's account every year, so the standard liability reserve test here applies to DB plans only. DC contributions are on the DB vs DC retirement pension calculator page.
When does the actuarial check result arrive?
Act Art. 16(2) says within 6 months after the end of each business year. For a company with a December year end, that is by the end of June the following year (our arithmetic).
Sources
- National Law Information Center — Employee Retirement Benefit Security Act Arts. 16(1) to (4) and 17(1) to (5) — text (current version, in force 18 September 2026, Act No. 21475; checked 19 November 2026). Standard liability reserve and minimum reserve, the actuarial check and notices, closing a shortfall, offset and refund, benefit payment and the 14 days.
- National Law Information Center — Enforcement Decree Arts. 5(1) and (2), 6(1), 7(1) and (2), and 8 item 4 — text (current version, in force 24 March 2026, Presidential Decree No. 36220; checked 19 November 2026). The 80% delegation, the notified rate for past service, notice to workers, 95% and a third within 1 year, exceptions to full payment.
- National Law Information Center — Enforcement Rule Arts. 4-2, 5 and 6 — text (current version, in force 12 July 2022, Ministry of Employment and Labor Ordinance No. 359; checked 19 November 2026). Minimum funding ratio of 100% from 1 January 2022, how the standard liability reserve is worked out, and the 12-month average with the 90% to 110% band.
- National Law Information Center — Minimum funding ratio of DB plans for past service — text (Ministry of Employment and Labor Notice No. 2022-37, in force 13 April 2022; table and formula read from enlarged page images; checked 19 November 2026). The past-service rate table for periods from 1 January 2022 and the formula for the whole membership period.
- Not read. The provisions on actuarial assumptions (discount and wage growth rates), the wording of the shortfall rule before its 2023 amendment, the Wage Claim Guarantee Act, the actuarial check forms in the supervisory regulation, Ministry rulings and statistics, and the sanctions for not closing a shortfall.
- What we added. Turning “a third of the shortfall ratio” into the amount (minimum reserve − reserve) ÷ 3 with fractions rounded up, dropping fractions on the 90% and 110% amounts, reading the refund as the part above the 150% line, and five examples (standard liability reserve ₩1,200,000,000, item 2 amount ₩1,100,000,000, reserves of ₩1,080,000,000, ₩1,160,000,000, ₩1,860,000,000 and ₩1,000,000,000, 12-month average ₩850,000,000).
The checker script was checked against a separate Python version of the same arithmetic over 720 cases for each of the Korean and English pages, with no mismatches.
Where to check further
- The DB plan's managing pension provider — the actuarial check (item 1 and 2 amounts, reserve valuation) and progress on closing a shortfall.
- Ministry of Employment and Labor customer centre — minimum reserve and the duty to close a shortfall.
Written 19 November 2026. The content restates the source text; the readings and arithmetic are ours.


